Order Up!
At: The Swift Creek Mill Theatre, 17401 U.S. Route One, Chesterfield, VA 23834
Performances: July 12 – August 2, 2025
Ticket Prices: $44-49. Ask about discounts for students, seniors, and veterans.
Info: (804) 748-5203 or https://www.swiftcreekmill.com
A Theater Reflection by Julinda D. Lewis
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, there’s something about summer that demands a musical. I also have a soft spot for diners and shows that take place in diners. (See my review of Waitress, another summer musical set in a diner: https://jdldancesrva.com/2025/07/12/waitress/ ) The Spitfire Grill, by James Valcq (music and book) and Fred Alley (lyrics and book) is particularly heartwarming.
In his director’s notes, Tom Width sums it up: “I find the show to be ‘hometown gold’ with its themes of family, heartbreak, resilience, and redemption along with a healthy dose of downhome charm and humor – all wrapped up in a musical score that rings true to the nature of its setting.” Nothing more needs to be said, but I’ll say a few more things anyway.
A stereotypical musical often feature a predictable plot, idealized characters, romantic storylines, upbeat tunes, elaborate choreography, and a happy ending. The Spitfire Grill has many of these characteristics but neatly sidesteps familiar tropes and simplistic portrayals of characters in favor of more complex individuals involved in less familiar situations and more unpredictable relationships.
Our first glimpse of our heroine, Percy, is from behind bars, just before she is released from prison where she has spent the past five years. By the end of Act 1, the plot still has not revealed why Percy was in prison – although I had my suspicions (based on her age and the length of her sentence), which were confirmed later in Act 2 with a conversation between Percy and her new friend Shelby.
Percy is not the only character with a secret. Her new – and reluctant – employer and ultimately friend, Hannah, also carries a heavy burden she needs help to let go. Perhaps Hannah’s hip problem and subsequently fall are overly active metaphors for her crippling burden. There is, after all, a longstanding literary history of spiritual meaning attached to dislocated or injured hips associated with struggle, growth, a turning point, or transformation.
I loved the raw and genuine relationship that develops between the two women portrayed by Lindsey Zelli as the broken but remarkably resilient young woman who is Percy Talbott and Joy Williams as the no-nonsense but tenderhearted matriarch Hannah Ferguson. Offering a counter to these two is Grey Garrett as Shelby Thorpe. A bit older than Percy, Shelby lacks Percy’s grit and independence but has the advantage of discernment and comes into her own under the tempering tension created by navigating Percy’s grittiness and Hannah’s steeliness. (Hmm. This made me think of the trio of women in Waitress, as well, and how each contributed something the other lacked, but I digress.) At one point Percy says, “Do you think if a wound goes deep enough the healing can hurt just as bad as what caused it?”
Offering a welcome comedic element is Effy Krayneck, the little town of Gilead, Wisconsin’s postmistress and self-appointed gossipmonger. When there isn’t any gossip to monger, Effy just makes up some juicy tidbit to smear around the diner like jelly on toast. Since Percy is the newest resident in town, the lion’s share of gossip is about her. Tara Callahan Carroll plays this role with great timing and just the right amount of exaggeration. But even Effy’s penchant for histrionics and hyperbole has a basis in community care. From what I could tell, the people who daily gather in Hannah’s Spitfire Grill are her chosen family, the people who really matter to her.
Jeff Ashworth treads carefully and with confidence in the roll of Sheriff Joe, the town’s law enforcement as well as Percy’s parole officer, friend, and potential love interest. Percy’s rebuff of Joe’s premature marriage proposal may or may not signal an end to any romantic relationship between the two of them, but it definitely causes a ripple in the usual happily ever after ending one expects in a musical.
Likewise, “it’s complicated” could be applied to the relationship between the soft-spoken Shelby and her husband Caleb, who is played with palpable tension by Scott Melton. Caleb, who is also Hannah’s nephew and gratuitous caretaker, appears to be at least a decade older than Shelby. He clings to an outdated sense of patriarchy and is highly resistant to change. There is a lot of love in Gilead, Wisconsin, but it doesn’t necessarily seem to be the romantic kind.
And then the authors introduce a mythical, mystical supernatural element. It’s subtle yet powerful. A nameless character identified in the program only as The Visitor brings a surprise revelation. Like the concept of a dislocated hip, the concept of a “visitor” comes attached to the idea of a catalyst for change, a disruption that forces needed transformation.
The Visitor in The Spitfire Grill makes several significant appearances but never speaks. Adding to this sense of mystery, The Visitor is played by Brian Vaughan or Austen Linder. Vaughan filled the role during the Wednesday matinee I viewed and joined Zelli to beautifully recreate a scene that had special meaning for Percy, a scene that gave Percy hope as she prepared to re-enter the world after prison. I’m not aware of the authors’ intent – it could simply be a result of the character’s earlier trauma (explained in the development of the story) but setting this scene in silence was more effective than it could ever have been if The Visitor spoke.
The Spitfire Grill is folksy or country, depending on your perspective. Lines like Effy’s enigmatic “if you’ve got the thread, you’ll find the needle” make perfect sense in this atmosphere. The accents are broad, and the singing is soulful and haunting. At one point, as Percy sings about jumping out of the frying pan into the fire, Lindsey Zelli quite casually holds a note for an impressively long time while swatting flies with a spatula. Drawn together by the unlikely device of a raffle, the cast moved together like a well-oiled ensemble through director Tom Width’s simple but genuine set. There seemed to be a concerted effort to portray real people that stirred the edges of our collective memory, rather than characters acting for our entertainment, and that’s what made The Spitfire Grill so satisfying. Order up!
Here’s a link to a video preview of The Spitfire Grill: https://www.facebook.com/swiftcreekmilltheatre/videos/1486417315855918 or www.swiftcreekmill.com
———-
Julinda D. Lewis, EdD is a dancer, minister of dance, teacher, and writer who was born in Brooklyn, NY and currently resides in Eastern Henrico County. When not writing about theater and dance, she teaches dance history at VCU and low impact dance fitness classes to seasoned movers like herself and occasionally gets to perform.
———-
THE SPITFIRE GRILL
Music & Book by James Valcq
Lyrics & Book by Fred Alley
Based on the filmy Lee David Zlotoff
Directed by Tom Width
CAST
Lindsey Zelli as Percy Talbott
Jeff Ashworth as Sheriff Joe
Joy Williams as Hannah Ferguson
Grey Garrett as Shelby Thorpe
Tara Callahan Carroll as Effy Krayneck
Scott Melton as Caleb Thorpe
Brian Vaughan or Austen Linder as The Visitor
Catherine McMullan U/S for Percy Talbott
ORCHESTRA
Shellie Johnson Keyboard Conductor
Finn Koehler Synthesizer
Chris Johnston Violin
Ed Drake Guitar/Mandolin
CREATIVE TEAM
Directed by Tom Width
Musical Direction by Shellie Johnson
Scenic Design by Tom Width
Lighting Design by Steve Koehler
Costume Design by Maura Lynch Cravey
Technical Direction by James Nicholas
PRODUCTION STAFF
Producing Artistic Director …. Tom With
Lead Carpenter ….. Peter Prout
Stage Manager ….. Sandy Lambert
Assistant Stage Manager/Props ….. Tom Width
Light Board Operator ….. Brent Deekens
Set Crew ….. Peter Prout, Brent Deekens, Hailey Bean, PJ Llewellyn, Thomas Doersch, Paul Deiss
Lighting Crew ….. Brent Deekens
Photographer ….. Daryll Morgan
Wig Design ….. Alia Radabaugh
Time and Place:
A Small Town, not long ago
Run Time:
About 2 hours, with 1 fifteen-minute intermission
Performances:
July 12 – August 2, 2025
Thursdays, Fridays, Saturdays at 8:00PM
Select Wednesdays at 2:30PM
Tickets:
Regular $44-49. Discounts for Seniors, Military & Veterans
Photographer: Daryll Morgan
The Spitfire Grill premiered off-Broadway at the Duke Theatre on 42nd Street on September 7, 2001.
MUSICAL NUMBERS
Act One
A Ring Around the Moon ….. Percy
Hannah’s Harangue ….. Hannah
Somethin’s Cookin’ at the Spitfire Grill ….. Company
Hannah Fell Down ….. Effy
Hannah Had a Son ….. Shelby
When Hope Goes ….. Shelby
Ice and Snow ….. Caleb, Joe and Effy
Shelby’s Ad ….. Shelby
The Colors of Paradise ….. Percy and Shelby
Diggin’ Stone ….. Caleb
This Wide Woods ….. Joe and Percy
Forgotten Lullaby ….. Hannah
Shoot the Moon ….. Hannah and Company
Act Two
Opening, Act II ….. Shelby, Percy and Hannah
Come Alive Again ….. Hannah and Company
Foret for the Trees ….. Joe
Wild Bird ….. Shelby
Sunrise ….. Percy
Shine ….. Percy
Way Back Home ….. Hannah
Dear Mrs. Ferguson ….. Effy and Joe
The Last Letters ….. Shelby and Percy
Finale ….. Company








Make a one-time, monthly or annual donation to support rvart review
Make a monthly donation
Make a yearly donation
Choose an amount
Or enter a custom amount – no amount is too small or too large
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
DonateDonate monthlyDonate yearly





































