A Musical Journey to Empowerment
A Theater Review by Julinda D. Lewis
By: Virginia Repertory Theatre (Virginia Rep), The Barksdale Season
At: the November Theatre Arenstein Stage, 114 West Broad St, Richmond VA 23220
When: June 21 – August 3, 2025
Ticket Prices: $39-$68
Info: (804) 282-2620 or www.virginiarep.org
It’s summer, and that means it must be time for a great big musical. That is exactly what VaRep delivered with Waitress, a popular musical, based on a 2007 film. The staged version ran on Broadway from April 2016 until January 2020 and returned for a limited engagement in 2021. Now, it’s right here in River City and friends who know wear big smiles as they tell me – who did not see it on Broadway – that the set is “just like” the Broadway set.
Whether it is or not, Mercedes Schaum’s scenic design is filled with simple, multi-tasking moving parts that evoke the feel of a small-town southern diner, but easily transforms into a living room, an ob-gyn office, or a bus stop. The diner even serves as a wedding venue for one of the waitresses.
Jenna, played by Emelie Faith Thompson, is the main character. Jenna, a waitress and pie chef at Joe’s Pie Diner, is trapped in an abusive marriage, and at the beginning of the show she discovers – much to her chagrin – that she is pregnant. The thick of the plot involves joining along on the journey as Jenna navigates the twists and turns of life, following an unlikely path to empowerment. Along the way, she has an unlikely affair with her doctor, resorts to hiding money from her husband, Earl, and explores the possibility of following her dreams via a pie baking contest. Her goal – and the moral of the story – is to achieve a life that is more than just “happy enough.”
Currently based in the Washington, D.C. area, Thompson may be familiar to Richmond audiences who saw Mamma Mia on this same stage the summer of 2022 [https://jdldancesrva.com/2022/06/26/mamma-mia/]. Thompson was well cast as Jenna, bringing empathy and authenticity to the role. Jenna is a complex character, given to indecisiveness and questionable choices, while balancing – no, while juggling – kindness, caring, the need for self-fulfillment, and the restrictions of real life. Thompson does all of this with the help of a strong voice that soars in all the right places – and the assistance of a stellar supporting cast.
Fellow waitstaff Becky (Miya Bass) and Dawn (Kylee Márquez-Downie), and the sometimes curmudgeonly Cal (William Vaughn) the short order cook and manager of Joe’s Pie Diner are the regulars who form the backbone of the diner and the musical. Becky appears to be the oldest of the three. She offers wisdom and wit, both of which come with the territory of having a disabled husband at home. Like Jenna, she enters into a surprising relationship. Dawn is the youngest and her social insecurities and awkwardness make her appear even moreso. All three share an unshakable, enviable love and loyalty.
Equally essential are Terence Sullivan as Dr. Pomatter – a caring and supportive physician who takes things beyond the intent of the hypocritic oath, and Jenna’s controlling and insecure husband, Earl, played by Greg Twomey. Dawn’s love interest, Ogie (Bear Manescalchi) is an unforgettably quirky and endearing character, but my personal favorites among the supporting characters are Nurse Norma (played by Imani Blair Crosby) and Joe, the owner of Joe’s Pie Diner, played by none other than Joe Pabst.
Nurse Norma turns a blind eye to the shenanigans perpetrated by Jenna and Dr Pomatter , and Crosby’s facial expressions, double-takes, and comedic timing in the most awkward situations are pure gold. Did I say that Cal was curmudgeonly? I should take that back. Joe takes the prize for being curmudgeonly, but he is quietly observant and becomes a significant source of support for Jenna. Since this was my first time seeing Waitress, I cannot imagine anyone other than Pabst in this role. Warm, prickly, paternal but not patriarchal in the toxic sense – Pabst/Joe is the source of the pivotal, transforming moment that changes everything for Jenna.
While filled with music and comedy, Waitress is also about friendship, loyalty, empowerment, self-efficacy, and the healing power of baking. Yum!
———-
Julinda D. Lewis is a dancer, teacher, and writer who was born in Brooklyn, NY and now lives in Eastern Henrico County. When not writing about theater, she teaches dance history at VCU and low impact dance fitness classes to seasoned movers like herself and occasionally gets to perform.
———-
WAITRESS
Book by Jessie Nelson
Music and Lyrics by Sara Bareilles
Directed by Rick Hammerly
Based upon the motion picture written by Adrienne Shelly
Cast
Jenna …………………………….. Emelie Faith Thompson
Becky …………………………….. Miya Bass
Dawn ……………………………… Kylee Márquez-Downie
Cal ………………………………… William Vaughn
Joe ………………………………… Joe Pabst
Earl ……………………………….. Greg Twomey
Nurse Norma/
Ensemble/U/S Becky….. Imani Blair Crosby
Dr. Pomatter …………………….. Terrance Sullivan
Ogie ……………………………… Bear Manescalchi
Ensemble, U/S Jenna ………….. Lindy Pokorny
Ensemble, U/S Dr. Pomatter……Calvin Malone
Ensemble, U/S Dawn…………… Brie Ramirez
Ensemble, U/S Ogie …………… Mason Jett
Ensemble, U/S Earl …………….. Patrick Rooney
Ensemble, U/S Cal……………… David Ramirez
Ensemble, U/S Nurse Norma…. Sarah White Pruden
Ensemble ……………………….. Audrey Baker
Ensemble ……………………….. Jennifer Lent Hamilton
Ensemble ……………………….. Garrett D. Reese
Lulu ………………………………. Emily Goodman, Phoebe Janosik, Josie Sledd
Swing …………………………….. Maria Carpinelli
Swing …………………………….. Joey Gravins
Band
Keyboard 1/Conductor ……….. Leilani Fenick
Keyboard 2 ……………………….. Ian Krauss
Guitar 1 ……………………………. Forrest Link
Guitar 2 ……………………………. Jeremiah Martin
Cello ……………………………….. Ned Haskins
Bass ………………………………… Beatrice Kelly
Drums ……………………………… Bentley Cobb
Direction & Design
Directed by ……………………… Rick Hammerly
Music Direction …………………… Leilani Fenick
Choreography ……………………. Paul Dandridge
Scenic Design …………………….. Mercedes Schaum
Costume Design ………………….. Sarah Grady
Lighting Design …………………… Joe Doran
Production Design ……………….. Dasia Gregg
Sound Design …………………….. Jonathan Pratt
Stage Management ………………. Abby Bobb
Fight & Intimacy Direction ….. Casey Kaleba
For This Production
Assistant Stage Manager ……… Donna Warfield
Production Assistant ……………. Katie Willard-O’Neill
Dance Captain ………….…………… Calvin Malone
Assistant Lighting Designer …. Kacey Yachuw
Carpenters ……………………………… Liz Allmon, Avery Glenn, Van Montes
Scenic Artist …………………………… Julie Gallager
Electricians …………………………….. Liz Allmon, Weston Corey
Stitchers ………………………………… Genna Beth Davidson, Sarah Grady,
Mary Nagler
Deck Crew ………………………… Lilith Fulcher-Davis, Daryus Gazder, Amber
Hooper, Devon Kistler
Fly Rail Operators ………………… Justin Janke, Mark Persinger, Shawn
Goodman, Hans Paul
Wardrobe Supervisor ……………. Emily Andrew Mateos
Dresser …………………………….. Rowan Sullivan
Audio Engineer …………………… Jonathan Pratt
Light Board Engineer …………….. Jeff Meisner
Follow Spot Operators …………… Terra Comer, Logan Graves, Reese Hardy,
Kacey Yachuw
Photographer ……………………… Aaron Sutten
Videographer ……………………… Austin Lewis
Front Cover Photography ………… Ben White
Ticket Information
Box Office: (804) 282-2620
Ticket Prices: $39 – $68
Performance Schedule
June 21 – August 3, 2023 with performances
Thursdays, Fridays, and Saturdays at 7:00 PM, Saturdays at 2PM, Sundays at 3PM, and select Wednesday evenings and matinees.
Run Time
The play runs for approximately 2 hours 15 minutes; with one 15-minute intermission
World Premiere produced by the American Repertory Theatre at Harvard University, August 2, 2015
Originally Produced on Broadway by Barry and Fran Weissler, Norton and Elayne Herrick
Musical Numbers
Act 1
What’s Inside ………………… Jenna and Company
Opening Up ………………..…. Jenna, Becky, Dawn, Cal and Company
The Negative …………………. Jenna, Becky, Dawn
What Baking Can Do ………. Jenna
When He Sees Me ………..…. Dawn
It Only Takes a Taste ………. Dr. Pomatter, Jenna
You Will Still Be Mine ……… Earl
A Soft Place to Land …………. Jena, Becky, Dawn
Never Getting Rid of Me …… Ogie and Company
Bad Idea …………………………….. Jenna, Dr. Pomatter
Act 2
I Didn’t Plan It ………………. Becky
Bad Idea (Reprise) …………. Jenna, Dr. Pomatter, Becky, Cal, Dawn, Ogie
and Company
Mama’s Pie Song …………… Jenna
You Matter to Me …………… Dr. Pomatter, Jenna
I Love You Like a Table ….. Ogie, Dawn and Company
Take It From An Old Man ….. Joe and Company
She Used to Be Mine …………… Jenna
What’s Inside (Reprise) ……… Company
Everything Changes (Part 1) .. Jenna, Becky, Dawn
Everything Changes (Part 2) .. Jenna and Company
Opening Up (Finale) ……………… Company
Photo Credits Aaron Sutten



Make a one-time, monthly, or annual donation to show how much you love rvart review!
Make a monthly donation
Make a yearly donation
Choose an amount
Or enter a custom amount – no amount is too small OR TOO LARGE!
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
Your contribution is appreciated.
DonateDonate monthlyDonate yearly